The debate continues between Mac and Windows at Rowell Annex, but this week we thought we’d look at the question a little more practically. First of all, what exactly do we mean by Mac vs. Windows? And secondly, are Macs or Windows better in different situations?
What’s the Debate?
If you’ve ever seen those Mac vs. PC ads on tv (with the “mac guy” young and hip and the “PC guy” in a frumpy suit) then you are very familiar with the debate. By Mac, we are talking about any Apple computer using an Apple operating system.
When we say Windows, we’re talking about computers that use one of the Windows operating systems. We’ve referred to them as PCs, even though we understand that even a Mac is a personal computer. (Mac vs. PC just rolls off the tongue a little smoother.)
We’re striving to be as fair as we can in our analysis of these different brands of computer. The most basic Macs tend to cost around $1,000, so it’s not equal to compare a MacBook Air with a $300 Dell Inspiron. Macs can lean towards the more expensive side, but it’s all about what you’re looking for. You can buy a $2,000 Windows computer just as easily as you can buy a $2,000 Mac.
And of course, there are some operating systems that didn’t even make it into our debate. In our Mac vs. PC poster in the waiting room of Rowell Annex, one customer cleverly wrote Linux in between the both sides. Linux is an open source operating system that is such a niche preference it didn’t make into our debate arena.
Is One Better? Or Are They Just Different?
So now that we’ve decided what each side means, the real question is whether one is superior, or if they’re just different? First of all, when matters of personal preference are involved, it’s tough to say that something is “better.” For someone who has never used a Mac, their experience using Windows is probably always going to be better compared to using an Apple OS.
Judging by the amount of stickers you see pasted on the back of MacBooks, it’s not hard to be convinced that Mac users are more art and design-oriented. Some people are just going to be more interested in customizing their desktop than customizing their hardware. Macs are still the choice computers for designers, which seems to be based on their speed, reliability, and user-friendly nature. However, Adobe design programs are not exclusive to Mac, so there is no reason a designer wouldn’t have just as much luck with a quality PC that had similar specifications.
The same can be said for gaming. Obviously a Macbook Pro isn’t going to hold up against a high end custom PC, but unless a game simply isn’t Mac-compatible, there’s no reason a Mac won’t work for casual gaming.
Our Advice
The one, conclusive difference that we can point out, is that Apple works on a system of having highly-integrated hardware and software. That potentially can lead to more expensive repairs and less customization, but is typically more reliable and user-friendly.
Windows operating systems do have lower prices. Kevin Andrews, a senior analyst in the IS department, explained, ”Apple hardware is manufactured by one company, unlike hardware for Windows. This competition between [Windows] hardware vendors drives the price down.” PCs can sometimes be a better value on the dollar, but customers should put research into a product before they invest, because there is a range of quality across brands.
For students looking to purchase a new computer, Matt Suprenant, an Academic Server Administrator for the IS department, said to think about of software you’ll be using in order to make an informed choice. “Look up the names of the software you want to use, browse forums and get feedback from users as to why they use what they use.” Of course, if you’re torn between the two operating systems, there are options like Bootcamp, which allow you to run Windows on a Mac.
If you’d like more information, check out this informative article that gives another comparison between the types of machines. And if you’ve got other points in the Mac vs. Windows debate, comment below!
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.